Review: Carbonell Olive Oil

carbonellI have to tell you about Carbonell olive oil — and not just because the company sent me a free bottle. No! I have to tell you about Carbonell olive oil because it is crazy good.

First, a confession. I know as a foodie, I’m supposed to take things like choosing an olive oil very seriously, but I’m mostly lazy about stuff like that. I keep a row of oils and flavored vinegars along my countertop, and I usually just buy — prepare to cringe — our grocery store house brand of extra-virgin olive oil. In my defense, it’s organic and has that nice, peppery taste you’re supposed to expect from “good” olive oil.

But this summer, Carbonell got in touch with me and asked me to try their extra-virgin olive oil. I added the bottle to the row of cooking soldiers, and it languished there until a few weeks ago when I remembered I should try it.

Now it’s almost gone because I find myself reaching for it every time I make a salad. Butter lettuce and scallions with lemon juice and Carbonell? Delicious! Artichoke hearts, hearts of palm, za’atar, vinegar, and Carbonell? Heavenly! Salad shrimp with red bell pepper, cucumber, chives, and Carbonell? Luscious.

I’m not even kidding around. The Carbonell web site promises a distinctive taste, and it’s true! It’s different than the other extra-virgin olive oils I’ve used. The flavor is unmistakably olive-y without being overly briny or too sharp. It somehow manages to be both intense and mellow at the same time, and it has a lovely texture: light and silky.

So now I have an opinion about olive oil. Who knew that would happen?!

More About Carbonell & Where To Buy

Carbonell has been produced and bottled in Cordoba, Spain since 1866, and the pretty art noveau lady holding the olive branch on the label is well-known in that country. The story on the web site about how the olives are harvested is quite romantic:

To guarantee the outstanding quality of Carbonell olive oil, the olives must be harvested when they are perfectly ripe. Harvesting olives is a process which has hardly changed over the centuries: the olives are picked by hand or are carefully knocked from the tree using long sticks. The olives then fall onto a soft canvas cloth to stop them bruising. The most important thing about picking olives is to make sure they are not damaged and that they are pressed within 24 hours of being picked.

That makes me want to fly to Spain, put on a flowing, gauzy dress, and sit in an olive grove at sunset, eating olives fresh off the trees.


Back to reality… after picking, the olives are taken to a mill, washed in cold eater, then crushed, along with their pits. The resulting paste is pressed and placed in a large, rotating drum to be spun. This “centrifuging” process separates the lighter olive oil from the heavier moisture, and voila! olive oil… ready to be drizzled with abandon on salads.

You can find Carbonell online at Amazon or offline in grocery stores and even Walmart (!).



The fine print: Carbonell sent me a complimentary bottle of olive oil, but there were no strings attached. If I didn’t sincerely enjoy this olive oil, I just wouldn’t have mentioned it at all.


My Favorite Kitchen Tools

This is just a rough estimate, but I'm pretty sure I've spent about 1000 hours in the kitchen testing recipes and prepping the food for photos for the new...

Read More
MMM: Making “Meat Dough”

Have you caught the frenzy of March Meatball Madness? (And are you enjoying the equally delicious celebration of Fug Madness? I love Fug Madness!) In...

Read More


  • Rachna says:


    I ordered Well Fed 2 today! It is on backorder until the end of October. I am looking forward to cooking recipes from the new book!

    • Mel says:

      Amazon is shipping WF2 now, so give it a few days, and I bet you’ll get a shipping notication. It’s always a little wonky when a book is new into inventory.

      • noblepower says:

        I just received an email from Amazon yesterday telling me that WF2 is being shipped to me a little earlier than they’d originally estimated – so hopefully Rachna will get her order a little earlier than expected as well. 🙂
        I can’t wait to dig in!

  • Matilda says:

    I’ve used this brand for years. It’s the only supermarket brand of olive oil I will buy.
    I do buy organic olive oil direct from the farmer at the farmers market, but it’s expensive (but top notch), so this comes in a close 2nd.

  • longhornval says:

    I love Spanish olive oil. I discovered it just a few weeks ago on a trip to southern Spain. Who knew it was so delicious! I’ll have to try this brand. 🙂

  • Sel says:

    The good thing about living in Spain is the olive oil. Spanish are the masters of olive oil. This brand is so common here that it made me smile when I saw you recommend it. I guess it’s like living in Brazil and enjoy coconut oil. I have a Brazilian friend. Once he was amazed how much I pay to get good quality coconut oil.
    Although I highly doubt these olives are organic…

  • Rosie Betteta says:

    I never try a better olive oil than Carbonell for Moore than 80 years my father n family use this oil s just the best oil I ever eat